I can remember very clearly how 10 years ago people were saying that the 9mm carbine or submachinegun was obsolete. This was when the 300 BLK platform was the cool kid and anybody who had a short barreled 5.56 was somehow doing it wrong for CQB.
Back then the only PCC I could think of was the Kel-Tec SUB2K.
The same critics are now singing praises over every new AR9 coming out saying its ideal for home defense and 9mm isn't anemic.
I never thought that carbines were obsolete. The US army has recently acquired a 9mm SMG.
There will always be a place for a pistol caliner carbine before, during, and after SHTF.
For the Zombie Apocalypse, I would recommend one for a few key reasons:
1. Ammunition availability: there was never a great rimfire drought for traditional pistol ammunition. In the Philippines, 5.56 and 7.62 are hard to come by in this present political climate.
2. Superior handling: It may lack the power and range of a proper rifle caliber, but a PCC can help a shooter land quicker and accurate fire in distances up to 100 yards far better than someone using a handgun.
Its so easy, smaller framed people could use it effectively.
More on that later.
3. Size: The smallest ones like the new IWI Uzi can fit inside the smallest of man-bags. An AR9 can be folded and stuffed into a laptop bag. How cool is that?
4. Training opportunities: Many countries such as mine have competitive venues for PCC matches. Just like in the USA, the Philippines has caught... the PCC bug. We even have carry permits for them too because of convoluted gun logic that for once works in our favor.
5. Variety: There is a PCC for everyone. The Angstadt UDP-9, Ruger PC carbines, IWI Tavor 9mm, Norinco MsP5 clone, CZ Scorpion, Sig MPX, JP Enterprise AR9s, CMMG Banshee, and a whole lot more have already seen tournament use here in the Philippines.
6. You could add a suppressor. Against the undead? 'Nuff said!
**********
East vs. West!
I'm really a NATO kind of guy and prefer the AR15 ergos aesthetics, but that Russian PDW looks slick, shoots really well, and is ideal for folks who want a gun that's good to go without all the tinkering AR-platform boys like to do.
I am likely to go with the Banshee for my stated reasons, plus parts availability and the delayed blowback technology in its bolt. An edge is and edge.
Think of a suppressed short barreled rifle with an optic that wakes up when you grab it, plus 33 rounds on tap.
With this in her hands she'd be incredibly potent against any foe, living or undead.
Things are looking up. With more choices becoming available to us and careful planning we could vastly improve our defensive capabilities.
Stay vigilant!